dailyplay.Your profile

Keynesian beauty contest game: Twothirdle Unlimited

Instant rounds against 49 bots · Replay freely

Bots, not people: you play against 49 simulated players.

Pick a whole number from 0 to 100. The winner is closest to ⅔ of the average of your number and the bots’ numbers.

What is a Keynesian beauty contest?

John Maynard Keynes compared investing to a newspaper contest where you win by picking the faces other readers will pick, not the ones you like best. The guess 2/3 of the average game is the cleanest version of the idea: you win by predicting how far everyone else will think ahead.

The idea comes from chapter 12 of Keynes’s The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936). Readers choose the six prettiest faces from a hundred photographs, and the prize goes to whoever picks closest to the most popular choices. So you pick the faces you expect others to like, or go one step further and anticipate “what average opinion expects the average opinion to be”, which Keynes called the third degree. He argued that professional investors play the same game: a price can rise because traders expect other traders to buy, not because the company is worth more, which is one way to explain market bubbles.

Who are the bots?

Each round draws 49 simulated players. About a fifth pick almost at random; most stop after one or two steps of reasoning (around 33 or 22); a few go deeper or straight to 0. That mix follows published experiments: in Rosemarie Nagel’s 1995 lab study, first-round players averaged about 36, and in the Financial Times reader contest of 1997 the winning number was 13. They are bots: Unlimited rounds never count toward the daily game, and the daily game never contains bots.

Unlimited or daily?

Unlimited is practice: a new crowd every round, results at once. The daily Twothirdle is one shared round with real players, final at midnight New York time. See how past daily crowds played.